News, tips, advice, support for Windows, Office, PCs & more. Tech help. No bull. We're community supported by donations from our Plus Members, and proud of it
Home icon Home icon Home icon Email icon RSS icon
  • General hardware troubleshooting

    Home Forums AskWoody support PC hardware Questions: How to troubleshoot hardware problems General hardware troubleshooting


    This topic contains 1 reply, has 2 voices, and was last updated by

     BobbyB 1 year, 4 months ago.

    • Author
    • #176201 Reply

      Da Boss

      From an anonymous poster:

      The point should be to encourage people to actually check their hardware. Hard drive tests are easy to do and only modestly hard to interpret properly. Memtest is hard due to lack of good tools (OEM tools vary, windows memtests doesn’t push the hardware very hard, 3rd party tools can be reliable but are sometimes buggy and may require UEFI — plus the UEFI itself has to be non-buggy). Establishing a baseline on your hardware as soon as possible is a good idea, finding defects on day 1 of the warranty is a good time to find them. You don’t want to be saying “is this a bug in memtest, or a bug with my hardware” while you are trying to rule out faulty ram.

      I’ve seen people say they’ve tested hard drive and ram and still can’t figure out what’s wrong with their machine.
      Running a single threaded memtest for only 30 minutes isn’t a very thorough test. (on the other hand, running a good test might be a challenge — or even impossible on some hardware)
      Checked the hard drive how? “Ran chkdsk” So you checked the logical integrity of your filesystem, OK, what were the results? “There were results? …ok… After that I further stressed the hard drive (which I still haven’t properly tested) with a OS corruption test. Let me guess I was supposed to look at the results of that too?”

      1. Check for faulty hardware
      2. Check for (and fix) filesystem corruption (not on faulty hardware!).
      3. Check for (and fix) OS corruption (not on faulty hardware!).
      4. Didn’t succeed? Prepare for an OS reinstall/backup-restore. Recover your files and data, make new backup (just in case). Mitigate faulty hardware (usually by replacement). Restore to alternate hard drive (don’t plug in old and alt at the same time!), find uncorrupt backup.

      Bad ram ranges from (in no particular order):
      So bad the computer can’t boot very far (before the HD is mounted for writing) — hooray, your filesystem / OS wasn’t corrupted (before you knew something was wrong).
      So subtle that you will have a trivial number a bit flips in memory during your computer’s lifetime, you will neither notice (probably) or be able to detect the fault — hooray??
      Just barely enough to cause minor corruption to your filesystem / OS over several months, possible causing corruption of your backups and the filesystem(s) on your backup drives, sometimes even partially recoverable — the worst
      Moderate problems, you know something is wrong and you know right away, but quick enough to avoid breaking your OS? Maybe. Hopefully windows updates don’t start installing while you are troubleshooting (or are already half installed and waiting to reboot).

      Hard drives are easier:
      If you have evidence or good reason to suspect your hard drive has ever lost any of your data (smallest unit of measure being a sector), then you should replace the drive. Unless you don’t care about the data on the drive and the effort it would take to get back up and running should the drive vanish. Also keep in mind that for defective secondary drives IO stalls from the faulty secondary drive can cause wonky behavior for the running OS (which is on the main drive).

      1 user thanked author for this post.
    • #176253 Reply

      AskWoody Lounger

      When checking the health of your Machine I always find it most efficacious to Boot from a system disk e.g. Hirens or one of those other Linux Boot utility disks rather than run any sort of Diagnostic test from within Windows GUI e.t.c basically all the background process’s seem to get in the way. Most of the time if it fails to boot and you’ve done a Hardware upgrade, RAM, Graphics Card or just plain delved “under the hood” retrace your steps is normally a first port of call for me, followed by at the same time Hardware compatibility checks Matching RAM, SODIMM, DIM or for the “longer in the Tooth” folks Parity none Parity RAM if you’ve been delving in the parts Box at work or Home. As labels do become detached over time. Basic stuff I know but all useful in the Diagnosis Dept.
      Before Xmas last year I hit Problems with a couple of laptops, ostensibly with the HDD’s persistently unable to install an OS and run for more that a couple of Reboots. As they were S.M.A.R.T. enabled not a problem drop down in to Pre Boot environment and read the logs sure enough laden with faults. Hmm as SMART drives inevitably ship with onboard faults known at the Factory (seriously they do!) coupled with SMART is only a guide and not a 100% reliable more of a prediction of failure I wasn’t too concerned. Then I did a surface check, a couple of times sure enough they were displaying many bad sectors, going against advice I partitioned around them putting off the inevitable. Well same deal again OS wouldn’t install and “Horror of Horror’s” the bad sectors had moved. How does that work? well some times a little persistence of thought about How a “Spinner” HDD works, if you take the fact that a Platter in a HDD is coated with a magnetic material that when it gets gouged or scratched the centrifugal force will fling it around the HDD enclosure hence the mysterious moveable “bad sectors” needless to say off to the Store for a brand new HDD and an SSD (needed no second bidding to treat myself to one of them 🙂 ) Job done. Now here’s the thing sat here is a 2001 old XP machine that the Airlines cheerfully destroyed the screen on yet the HDD is unscathed after all these years although its not meteoric in performance it still works well. Lastly, as I can hear the ZZZZ’s from here should you feel the need to delve under the Hood albeit Desktop or a branded Laptop. Have a look on “YouTube” for howto’s so at least its not going to be a “shot in the dark” when you crack the case, Its handy for stuff like that and not only for the “Tide Pod” consuming fraternity as most folk think it is lol 🙂

      1 user thanked author for this post.

    Please follow the -Lounge Rules- no personal attacks, no swearing, and politics/religion are relegated to the Rants forum.

    Reply To: General hardware troubleshooting

    You can use BBCodes to format your content.
    Your account can't use Advanced BBCodes, they will be stripped before saving.