LEGAL BRIEF By Max Stul Oppenheimer, Esq. That’s a big ask. In a previous column, I explained why law always lags technology. To summarize, case law i
[See the full post at: Note to Congress: Please try to keep up]
![]() |
There are isolated problems with current patches, but they are well-known and documented on this site. |
SIGN IN | Not a member? | REGISTER | PLUS MEMBERSHIP |
-
Note to Congress: Please try to keep up
Home » Forums » Newsletter and Homepage topics » Note to Congress: Please try to keep up
- This topic has 7 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 4 months, 3 weeks ago.
AuthorTopicMax Stul Oppenheimer
AskWoody_MVPViewing 3 reply threadsAuthorReplies-
samak
AskWoody PlusI don’t understand why problem 1 is a problem at all:
“if AI machines cannot be authors or inventors, their work cannot be copyrighted or patented at all”Somebody owns the AI machine. They copyright or patent whatever their machine authors or invents. Am I missing something ?
Windows 10 Home 22H2, Acer Aspire TC-1660 desktop + LibreOffice, non-techie
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
rc primak
AskWoody_MVPI would think the laws which assign patent and copyright rights to employers could be extended to make this point explicit. In short, since as of now AI is created by humans, anything AI creates which is original enough to qualify, should be held to the same standards as works and inventions people create while in the service of their employers. The biggest change I would foresee is if it were one day deemed that AI had created itself without human intervention. At that point, the AI itself would need to be treated as a person under the law. This would require revising laws and regulations. We are a long way from that happening.
-- rc primak
-
Max Stul Oppenheimer
AskWoody_MVPA perfectly rational approach. Unfortunately, both the Copyright Office and the Patent Office take a different view – in their view (supported at this point by two federal cases) only a human can create and creating the machine that creates doesn’t qualify. Higher courts may side with your view, or Congress may resolve the issue, but at this point legal authority rejects the approach. Which is not to say that is a good result.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
-
AmbularD
AskWoody PlusOh yes, creators do know and do very much care that their copyrighted work is being scraped and used to train AI without their permission, and they don’t like it one bit.
The biggest kerfuffle in progress is among visual artists. But just within the past few weeks, archiveofourown.org (AO3) has had fanfiction authors’ accounts slamming shut left and right, going registered-user-only to prevent, at least, future works from being used without their consent. For existing works, we figure it’s most likely too late.
How do we know it’s happening? Well, I’m not sure whether anyone can specifically identify text lifted from their own individual works. But terms have recently started popping up in AI-generated text that are extremely specific to certain fanfiction subgenres (and that may or may not be something the person using the AI wanted to see, which is another can of worms unto itself.)
Among numerous issues with this, it seems that various apps using this AI technology are not being created by the same people who set up the AI, but by developers who are licensing or leasing or otherwise obtaining permission to use it. So they have no idea where the AI’s dataset came from and no control over what information it does or doesn’t include. Copyright owners who don’t want their works used in this way in a particular app have no recourse.
If there’s a way to contact the creators of the AI itself (or even identify who they are) and request that something be excluded, so far I haven’t come across it.
i7-10700k - ASROCK Z590 Pro4 - 1TB 970 EVO Plus M.2 - DDR4 3200 x 32GB - GeForce RTX 3060 Ti FTW - Windows 10 Pro
Alex5723
AskWoody PlusOh yes, creators do know and do very much care that their copyrighted work is being scraped and used to train AI without their permission, and they don’t like it one bit.
The ministry of of justice in Israel declared that there are no copyright infringements when training AI using copyrighted material.
-
AmbularD
AskWoody Plus
ibe98765
AskWoody PlusThis will only be a problem until we achieve post-scarcity, often posited by SF writers, which will occur once we are able to easily get off planet Earth and spread throughout the solar system. At that point we will have access to unlimited resources, so there will be no need for ownership when everything is free. Patents go out the window then.
Viewing 3 reply threads -

Plus Membership
Donations from Plus members keep this site going. You can identify the people who support AskWoody by the Plus badge on their avatars.
AskWoody Plus members not only get access to all of the contents of this site -- including Susan Bradley's frequently updated Patch Watch listing -- they also receive weekly AskWoody Plus Newsletters (formerly Windows Secrets Newsletter) and AskWoody Plus Alerts, emails when there are important breaking developments.
Get Plus!
Welcome to our unique respite from the madness.
It's easy to post questions about Windows 11, Windows 10, Win8.1, Win7, Surface, Office, or browse through our Forums. Post anonymously or register for greater privileges. Keep it civil, please: Decorous Lounge rules strictly enforced. Questions? Contact Customer Support.
Search Newsletters
Search Forums
View the Forum
Search for Topics
Recent Topics
-
Just a fyi – I think I’ll skip on an Apple Vision Pro hardware section
by
Susan Bradley
4 hours, 25 minutes ago -
What’s wrong with Windows 11?
by
Ascaris
2 hours, 35 minutes ago -
Streaming an iPad to a standard TV
by
MrJimPhelps
16 minutes ago -
clone to make backup laptop
by
greenbergman
9 hours, 6 minutes ago -
Problems with sound and USB ports
by
StavRoss
8 hours, 31 minutes ago -
Can you use WUShowHide on Windows 11 version 21H2?
by
southieguy
4 hours, 59 minutes ago -
Can we control the changes to our operating systems?
by
Susan Bradley
5 hours ago -
Watch out for fake ‘Windows Defender’ scare
by
B. Livingston
4 hours, 21 minutes ago -
Diagnostics and testing? Get it all done in a flash.
by
Ben Myers
2 hours, 33 minutes ago -
Dip your toe into Visio Online
by
Peter Deegan
8 hours, 40 minutes ago -
Updating Win 10 Pro 21H2 to 22H2
by
bsqrd
6 hours, 42 minutes ago -
Changing mouse pointer options.
by
Artie
9 hours, 58 minutes ago -
Desktop or Laptop? What’s your choice?
by
Susan Bradley
41 minutes ago -
Anyone use Auslogics Bitreplica
by
WSjcgc50
1 day, 19 hours ago -
Unleashing the Gaming Revolution: CrossOver Mac’s DirectX 12 Support Update!
by
Alex5723
2 days, 8 hours ago -
Defender’s Offline Scan Fails to Run
by
E Pericoloso Sporgersi
1 day, 15 hours ago -
Mouse problem : cannot grab a window without maximizing it
by
Andy M
1 day, 21 hours ago -
End of support for Cortana in Windows
by
Alex5723
1 day, 7 hours ago -
Microsoft is really missing an advertising trick
by
Sky
2 days, 7 hours ago -
New MOVEit Transfer zero-day mass-exploited in data theft attacks
by
Alex5723
3 days, 7 hours ago -
Windows 11 Insider Preview build 25381 released to Canary
by
joep517
3 days, 8 hours ago -
Authenticating Email Address
by
IreneLinda
2 hours, 7 minutes ago -
Confusion about password protecting a folder in W10
by
Cthru
3 days, 10 hours ago -
I broke my right arm yesterday
by
Alex5723
1 day, 10 hours ago -
Kaspersky : iOS devices targeted with previously unknown malware
by
Alex5723
3 days, 6 hours ago -
Which Updates From Each List Are Safe to Install ?
by
TheFamilyIT
23 hours, 31 minutes ago -
AOL changes its web based email
by
Charlie
3 days, 6 hours ago -
Windows 11 Insider Preview build 23471 released to DEV
by
joep517
4 days, 8 hours ago -
Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 22621.1830 and 22624.1830 released to BETA
by
joep517
4 days, 8 hours ago -
Spyboy Defense Evasion Tool Advertised Online
by
Alex5723
4 days, 15 hours ago
Recent blog posts
- Can we control the changes to our operating systems?
- Watch out for fake ‘Windows Defender’ scare
- Diagnostics and testing? Get it all done in a flash.
- Dip your toe into Visio Online
- Desktop or Laptop? What’s your choice?
- Beware of Google’s .ZIP domain and password-embedded URLs
- Longstanding feature requests, and their status
- Three typing tutors — no more “hunt and peck”
Key Links
Want to Advertise in the free newsletter? How about a gift subscription in honor of a birthday? Send an email to sb@askwoody.com to ask how.
Mastodon profile for DefConPatch
Mastodon profile for AskWoody
Home • About • FAQ • Posts & Privacy • Forums • My Account
Register • Free Newsletter • Plus Membership • Gift Certificates • MS-DEFCON Alerts
Copyright ©2004-2023 by AskWoody Tech LLC. All Rights Reserved.