• 20 Windows updates installed without my permission!

    Home » Forums » AskWoody support » Windows » Windows 7 » Questions: Windows 7 » 20 Windows updates installed without my permission!

    Author
    Topic
    #497288

    I’ve always set my Windows Update policy to Download but Let Me Choose whether to install. Seeing that this month’s update was going to be a biggie I double-checked that I’d got it set like that because only a few weeks before I’d had to reinstall a friends laptop after a bad update experience (believe me, I tried everything – please don’t start a side-discussion on what else I might have tried).

    And down came 20 updates yesterday. I opened Windows Update to check them out but closed it again without clicking anything, intending to wait until Windows Secrets gave the all-clear.

    But on shutting the system down last night, it said please don’t power-off – installing 20 updates. HEY, I DIDN’T ASK FOR THAT!

    With some trepidation I booted up this morning and was relieved when it apparently came up cleanly.

    So what’s this – a new policy? Or do I blame the cat for pouncing on the mouse when I had my back turned?

    Regards – Philip

    Viewing 10 reply threads
    Author
    Replies
    • #1475130

      Do you have MSE by any chance? If you’ve switched Microsoft Update or Windows Update to “Notify but don’t download” or “Download but don’t install,” running the MSE installer switches Windows over to Automatic Updates without any notification and without asking for permission.

    • #1475133

      As I said, I checked recently and have checked again today that the policy is as I intended. I use Avast, not MSE.

    • #1475150

      There is a loophole sometimes in that WU can update itself automatically; so, it checks, finds an update for itself and installs it, that in turn allows it to switch to automatic updates for everything and you get them all…should find it switched to full automatic in settings though.
      Make sure nothing underneath is checked either, like allow all users to install updates or allow other Microsoft updates such as for Office.
      Also, a better setting is to check for updates but do not download or install without further approval.

      Easy way to remove unwanted updates [from the registry] AFTER they’ve been installed is just rollback with a system restore.

      • #1475151

        Again, as I said, I’ve checked the setting is as I intended. If no one else has seen this behaviour it looks like I’ll just have to blame the cat. Always a good strategy.

    • #1475192

      I’m assuming (never changed WU settings) that the setting only applies to Important Updates. Four of the updates provided yesterday were Critical.

      November Security Bulletin – https://technet.microsoft.com/library/security/ms14-nov

      I’ve also just noticed this on the settings page:

      38401-WU-Settings

      Could it suggest that it may have changed the settings after you checked?

    • #1475208

      Why is it that the numbers identifying the Windows Updates (7×64) never match those quoted by Susan Bradley in her update column?

    • #1475249

      Windows Update can only run if the service is running. On my Windows 7 system, the service is called “Windows Update” and has the service name “wuauserv”. To put Windows Update completely under your control, you an set up a batch file containing the following lines:

      sc config wuauserv start= auto (enables the service)
      net start wuauserv (starts it running)
      C:WINDOWSSystem32wuapp.exe startmenu (fires up the application, where you can “Check for updates” and select those you want to install))
      pause (to not allow the next commands until finished)
      net stop wuauserv (stops the service when you are finished with it)
      sc config wuauserv start= disabled (disables the service until next time you run this)
      pause (so you can see what happened before you quit)

      You may get some issues with UAC, but basically this only allows Windows Update to run when you want it to. For example, you can run it on the Friday after Patch Tuesday. You will also need to set Windows Update to “Off” in Action Center > Security, otherwise it may start to download updates immediately when you run this.

      The reason why the KBnnnnnnn numbers you see sometimes don’t match the numbers quoted by Susan is that there may be multiple fixes for a given problem, and the one offered to you will depend on your particular software configuration. You can check this out by following the “more information” link for an update, and looking at the list of systems affected.

    • #1476114

      OK, so now I’ve confirmed that with the setting “Download but let me choose whether to install”, it installs anyway when you shut down! (I used to hibernate overnight and rarely shutdown, but since fitting an SSD, booting is nearly as quick as waking from hibernation.)

      I have now specifically watched this happen twice with Windows Defender updates (frankly, I wish it’d just do them, like AV updates) but more seriously with yesterday’s emergency Windows out of cycle update.

      This is WRONG. I asked to choose and it’s doing it anyway!

      So as a temporary work-around, I’ve now set it to install automatically on a Thursday at 18.00 (UK time). That means that I’ll be waiting up to a week for Defender updates, but MS will have 2 days in which to pull a bad Windows update.

      Regards – Philip

      • #1476117

        OK, so now I’ve confirmed that with the setting “Download but let me choose whether to install”, it installs anyway when you shut down…

        On my systems I always set WU to “Check for updates but let me choose whether to download and install them”; have never had WU install updates unless I told it to.

        • #1476135

          On my systems I always set WU to “Check for updates but let me choose whether to download and install them”; have never had WU install updates unless I told it to.

          This is my experience on both my machines too, and they’re always switched off at night as well as during the day if I go out.

    • #1476120

      Interesting, Coochin. And you’re running Win7 and shutting down overnight?

      • #1476173

        Interesting, Coochin. And you’re running Win7 and shutting down overnight?

        Yes, four Win7 installations. I shut everything down overnight and if I am going to be away for more than an hour or two.

        WU checks for updates soon after Win7 starts up; if updates are available nothing further happens until I go into WU and tell it to install any updates I select.

    • #1476126

      Invoking above batch ideas! Bundeberra, do you run the batch file as a text file within a admin DOS-box?
      Years ago, I ran many many BAT files; however, now, since I have no idea how to get Windows 7 to see BATchfiles and run BATchfile, I open an admin-level DOS box and run the appropriate text files — is that what you do?

      After posting above, I got my own answer. After making the text files as given by Bundeberra, I copy’d them, renamed them as bat files, desktop shortcutted the processing one — right-clicked on it, and it awhile, but, it ran exactly as bb said it would! Pleriche, you and I received our solution, from bundeberra. 🙂

      "Take care of thy backups and thy restores shall take care of thee." Ben Franklin, revisted

    • #1476130

      OK, a bat file is a solution, of sorts. I’d just like Windows to do as it’s told! Can I trust it to do anything?

      • #1476131

        OK, a bat file is a solution, of sorts. I’d just like Windows to do as it’s told! Can I trust it to do anything?

        Your question is a little open-ended, for nothing is impossible for Microsoft and Windows. However, I tried the BATfile — and so far, Windows Update has not appeared. I’m off to work, I can read but cannot write — permissions beyond my reach 🙂

        BB’s batchfile:
        rem BATchfiling Windows Update
        sc config wuauserv start=auto
        net start wuauserv
        C:WINDOWSSystem32wuapp.exe startmenu
        pause
        net stop wuauserv
        sc config wuauserv start=disabled
        pause

        "Take care of thy backups and thy restores shall take care of thee." Ben Franklin, revisted

    • #1476147

      Windows Defender signature updates use the WU architecture/software but are not bound by the general WU settings. Defender has its own settings. As long as the WU service and associated services are running Defender will update signatures on its schedule. If your machine were left on all the time the Defender updates would be done in the background and you’d most likely never see them.

      Joe

      --Joe

    Viewing 10 reply threads
    Reply To: 20 Windows updates installed without my permission!

    You can use BBCodes to format your content.
    Your account can't use all available BBCodes, they will be stripped before saving.

    Your information: